(
NOTE: Welcome, LGF readers! And thanks for the link, Charles.)
Michelle Malkin
reports that YouTube took down a video she posted there, expressing her criticism of militant Islam. (It's available on her site
here.)
Yet YouTube seems to have no problem hosting viciously anti-Israel propaganda videos. Check out some examples
here,
here, and
here. (The last one in particular is so full of Jews-are-taking-over-the-world paranoia that it's almost a parody.)
How should YouTube determine where to draw the line between strongly-held political views, and unacceptably offensive content? Answer: It shouldn't. It shouldn't be in the viewpoint-regulation business. As is often said, the best response to offensive speech is more speech, not censorship.
I know YouTube is a business and wants to avoid controversy. But most people are smart enough to know that it doesn't endorse the message of any particular video uploaded to its site. And by censoring its user-generated content, YouTube is shooting itself in the foot.
Malkin quotes YouTube user
Intelsum, who theorizes that the site automatically pulls videos "flagged" as offensive by a large enough number of users and that Muslim groups are gaming the system, rallying their members to flag videos that criticize aspects of Islam, even though such videos don't violate YouTube's stated
terms of use.
If that's what's going on, it's a flaw in YouTube's moderation system and should be stopped. The real attraction of YouTube has been the sense that you can find anything there. But those days may be past. Now it seems that you can find only what YouTube, and its most aggressive user groups, think you should see.
FOLLOW-UP: Charles
notes that YouTube has since pulled the third anti-Israel video I linked above. However, this may have been due to copyright considerations, not issues of content, since the clip apparently used
MEMRI TV footage with the MEMRI logo covered up.
ANOTHER FOLLOW-UP: And now the first of the three anti-Israel videos has been pulled by YouTube, raising the possibility that hordes of LGF's "lizardoid minions" flagged it as offensive. This is not a positive development. I want these videos to be widely available, so people can see just how deranged and hate-filled Israel's opponents can be. A tit-for-tat censorship battle only leaves all of us less informed.